Dan J. Harkey

Master Educator | Business & Finance Consultant | Mentor

“A Travesty of a Mockery of a Sham”: The Perfect Description of Mortgage Brokerage in 2026

Few lines capture the daily reality of being a mortgage broker as perfectly as Woody Allen’s immortal outburst:

by Dan J. Harkey

Share This Article

Summary

“It’s a travesty of a mockery of a sham!” Every broker knows the feeling. You’ve pre-qualified the Borrower, packaged the file, cleared conditions twice, answered every question… And then an underwriter comes back asking for a letter of explanation for a letter of explanation.

You laugh.
You cry.
You repeat the quote.

Why does the line feel so accurate?
Because mortgage brokerage has become an industry where competence battles chaos every single day, you should feel proud of your resilience and adaptability.

The Modern Mortgage Broker: Professional Problem‑Solver in a World of Manufactured Problems

You Don’t Sell Loans—You Solve Obstacles

Your actual day-to-day job description isn’t “mortgage originator.”

It’s:

  • translator,
  • counselor,
  • financial analyst,
  • underwriter‑in‑training,
  • regulatory interpreter,
  • fire extinguisher,
  • therapist,
  • and sometimes a hostage negotiator.

All while juggling disclosure deadlines, Borrower expectations, and lender turn‑times that can shift without warning.

If success depended solely on skill, brokers would rule the world.

Because mortgage brokerage has become an industry where systems, not skill, cause most delays, highlighting the daily challenges brokers overcome—and that’s where the absurdity begins.

Conditions, Overlays, and the Theater of Compliance

A Broker’s Daily Reality

Modern lending is not simply about income, credit, assets, and collateral.
It’s about navigating a maze of:

  • Lender overlays that contradict agency guidelines
  • conditions that ignore the already‑provided documentation
  • DU/LPA findings that change after a resubmission
  • underwriters who request a bank statement from 2018 “just to be sure.”
  • compliance rules designed to prevent problems that no human has ever actually encountered

You’re not operating within a rational system.
You’re operating within a performance of risk management.

Everyone pretends the rules make sense.
Nobody believes they do.

Borrowers Think You Make the Rules—Until They Learn the Truth

You Are the Face of a Frustrating System

Brokers often get unfairly blamed for:

  • appraisal delays
  • underwriting decisions
  • compliance flags
  • automated system errors
  • investor overlays
  • turn‑time bottlenecks

Borrowers assume you control everything.
But you are the only part of the system actually working for them.

Yet you’re judged by:

  • the slowest AMC,
  • the pickiest underwriter,
  • the newest compliance requirement,
  • the least flexible investor overlay,
  • Or the one document the Borrower forgot to upload.

And still, you deliver.

Technology Promised Efficiency.  It Delivered More Steps.

Myth of Automation

The industry told brokers:

“Upload everything into the portal.  It will streamline the process.”

What happened?

  • New portals replaced old portals.
  • Systems don’t integrate.
  • Underwriters still ask for PDFs “just in case.”
  • Borrowers forget passwords to five different platforms.
  • Automation increases documentation, not reduces it.

The tech is impressive.
The results are not.

If Woody Allen were a mortgage broker, he would have said the line every morning before logging into Blend, Encompass, or Byte.

The Appraisal Circus

Precision Without Logic

Brokers live at the mercy of appraisals:

  • AMCs are assigning appraisers an hour away
  • Comparable sales from across the freeway, “because the computer says so.”
  • Revisions no one asked for
  • Reviewers who don’t understand the market
  • Turn‑times that shift from 5 days to 15 days overnight

The entire appraisal ecosystem functions like a legal disclaimer—
designed to shift responsibility, not reflect reality.

It’s no wonder deals get derailed by valuation guesswork that pretends to be science.

Why Brokers Still Win: You’re the Only One with Common Sense

The Mortgage Broker Advantage

Despite the chaos, brokers succeed because they:

  • understand multiple lenders’ programs
  • know how to restructure files creatively
  • can pivot quickly when guidelines change
  • communicate like human beings
  • educate borrowers who have been fed misinformation
  • fight for approvals instead of accepting arbitrary denials

In a world of rigid institutional processes, brokers remain flexible, adaptable, and human traits that keep them ahead and reinforce their value.

That is your competitive edge.

Takeaway: Say the Line—and Keep Closing

Mortgage brokerage isn’t broken.
It’s overloaded with rules, updates, overlays, and automated inefficiencies that pass for progress.

But brokers survive—and thrive—because they can still think, improvise, and act in the Borrower’s best interest.

When the system makes no sense,
when the portals freeze,
When the conditions contradict each other,
When the appraisal sinks the deal,
when the Borrower panics…

Remember the most accurate line ever written about this business:

“It’s a travesty of a mockery of a sham.”

Say it.
Laugh at it.
Then go ahead and close the loan anyway.

That’s what mortgage brokers do.