Dan J. Harkey

Educator & Private Money Lending Consultant

History of Manufacturing Consent: Edward Bernays

Edward Bernays was absolutely a propaganda specialist, though he preferred the term “public relations” after World War I because “propaganda” had developed a negative connotation.

by Dan J. Harkey

Share This Article

Summary

Why He’s Considered a Propaganda Specialist • WWI Work: Bernays worked on the U.S. Committee on Public Information, which used propaganda to rally American support for the war. • Book Propaganda (1928): He openly described propaganda as a necessary tool in democratic societies to shape public opinion. • Core Belief: “The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in a democratic society.”

His Approach

  • Applied psychology and mass communication to influence behavior.
  • Used symbols, emotions, and media to make ideas feel natural and inevitable.
  • Advocated for “engineering consent”—guiding people without them realizing it.

Edward Bernays is often called the “father of public relations”, but labeling him as the “father of mind control” is a bit of an exaggeration—though not entirely without reason. His work was about influencing public opinion, not about controlling individual minds.

Here’s the nuance:

1.     What Bernays Actually Did

  • Pioneered Modern PR: Bernays was a trailblazer in the field of public relations, applying psychological principles (especially from his uncle Sigmund Freud) to influence public opinion.
  • Framed Messaging: He understood that people are driven more by emotion and unconscious desires than by rational thought.
  • Created Campaigns: Famous examples include:
    • “Torches of Freedom” (1929): Linked women smoking to women’s liberation.
    • Bacon and Eggs: Marketed as the “hearty American breakfast.”
  • Core Idea: If you shape the narrative and symbols, you can shape behavior.

2.     Why People Call It “Mind Control”

  • Bernays believed in “engineering consent”—guiding the masses without them realizing it.
  • He wrote in Propaganda (1928):
    “The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in a democratic society.”
  • This sounds manipulative because it is—he saw it as necessary for managing complex societies, raising important ethical considerations for the audience to ponder.

3.     What He Was NOT

  • He didn’t invent propaganda or psychological influence (those existed long before).
  • He wasn’t a hypnotist or literal “mind controller.” His work was about mass persuasion through language, symbolism, and media.

4.     Engineering Consent

  • People don’t make decisions rationally; emotions and unconscious desires drive them.
  • Shape public opinion by framing ideas in ways that appeal to those instincts.

5.     Use of Authority and Social Proof

  • Align messages with trusted figures, experts, or institutions.
  • People follow what others (especially influencers) endorse.

6.    Create Associations

  • Link products or ideas to powerful symbols, values, or aspirations.
  • Example: Cigarettes as “freedom” for women (Torches of Freedom campaign).

7.     Leverage Media as a Multiplier

  • Use newspapers, radio, and later TV (today: social media) to amplify narratives.
  • Control the conversation by feeding stories to journalists and opinion leaders.

8.     Make It Seem Organic

  • Hide the sponsor’s hand; make campaigns appear as grassroots or public demand.
  • Example: Organizing “independent” events that were actually orchestrated.

10.     Tap into Group Identity

  • People act as members of groups, not as isolated individuals.
  • Target messaging to social, cultural, or professional identities.

11. Repetition and Consistency

  • Repeat key ideas across multiple channels until they feel like common sense.

12. Engineering Consent

Example:

  • Apple Product Launches
    Apple doesn’t just sell devices; it sells status and identity. The narrative is about being innovative, creative, and part of an elite group.

       .    Authority & Social Proof

Example:

  • Influencer Marketing on Instagram/TikTok
    Brands use influencers as trusted figures to endorse products, leveraging their authority within niche communities.

.    Create Associations

Example:

  • Nike’s “Just Do It”
    Associates shoes with empowerment, achievement, and personal greatness—not just footwear.

·      Media as a Multiplier

Example:

  • Coca-Cola’s Holiday Campaigns
    Coca-Cola uses TV, social media, and experiential marketing to reinforce the association between Coke and happiness/family gatherings.

.    Make It Seem Organic

Example:

  • Starbucks “Red Cup” Controversy
    Every year, social media debates about Starbucks’ holiday cup design feel spontaneous—but they drive massive free publicity.
  • Group Identity

Example:

  • Patagonia’s Environmental Branding
    Appeals to eco-conscious consumers who identify as responsible and adventurous.

.    Repetition & Consistency

Example:

  • McDonald’s “I’m Lovin’ It”
    A simple, repeated slogan across decades and platforms creates familiarity and trust.
  • Engineering Consent
  • Example: Campaign slogans like “Hope and Change” or “Make America Great Again” appeal to emotions and aspirations rather than policy details.
  • Why It Works: People vote based on feelings of identity and security, not spreadsheets of data.

.    Authority & Social Proof

  • Example: Endorsements from celebrities, respected leaders, or major organizations.
  • Why It Works: Voters trust familiar figures and assume “if they support it, it must be good.”

 .   Create Associations

  • Example: Wrapping candidates in patriotic imagery, family values, or economic prosperity.
  • Why It Works: People connect the candidate with symbols they already value.

 .   Media as a Multiplier

  • Example: Strategic leaks, press conferences, and viral social media clips.
  • Why It Works: News cycles amplify narratives, making them feel urgent and widely accepted.

 .   Make It Seem Organic

  • Example: “Grassroots” movements that are actually funded and organized by campaign PACs.
  • Why It Works: People trust what looks like genuine public support.

. Group Identity

  • Example: Messaging tailored to specific demographics (e.g., suburban moms, veterans, young voters).
  • Why It Works: People respond to appeals that affirm their identity and values.

. Repetition & Consistency

  • Example: Repeating key phrases like “Build Back Better” or “Drain the Swamp” across every speech and ad.
  • Why It Works: Familiarity breeds acceptance.