Dan J. Harkey

Educator & Private Money Lending Consultant

List Hidden Taxation in the American Enterprise System

If there is any question about the top tax bracket being 70% or more, think again. Hidden taxes are the culprit.

by Dan J. Harkey

Share This Article

Summary

Here are three hidden taxes that most Americans often overlook.

 ·       Inflationary creep- as inflation goes up, the price of goods goes up, and the dollar will purchase, say, 10% less. That is a tax.

·       Legal and court costs in America account for 10% of the gross domestic product. That is a tax.

·       Bureaucracy creeps- Every new law and regulation makes it more challenging to do business and live an ordinary life. Reporting and regulation account for at least 10% or more of the cost of goods and services, which must be passed on to the consumer.

·       A 2023 study for the National Association of Manufacturers estimated that federal regulations cost the U.S. economy about $3.08 trillion annually, which translates to roughly $22,962 per household or about 24% of average household income.

Here are some ordinary hidden taxes in the American system that many people pay without realizing it:

·       Medicare Tax (FICA) – Withheld from paychecks to fund Medicare; employees pay 1.45% and employers match it.

·       Self-Employment Tax – Covers Social Security and Medicare for self-employed individuals (15.3% combined).

·       Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) – Originally aimed at the wealthy, now affects many middle-income taxpayers.

·       Utility Taxes – Taxes on electricity and natural gas usage.

·       Cable and Communication Taxes – Taxes on cable TV, landline, and cellphone services.

·       Gasoline Tax – Federal (18.4¢/gallon) plus state taxes (average 23.44¢/gallon), making up about 11% of gas prices. In California, fill up your 20-gallon tank and pay $20 x $ 1.20 = $24 for just one fill-up.

a. State Excise Tax

·        61.2¢ per gallon (effective July 1, 2025, after a 1.6¢ CPI adjustment)

b. Federal Excise Tax

·        18.4¢ per gallon (unchanged nationwide)

c. Statewide Sales Tax on Fuel

·        2.25% on the base price of gasoline (plus local district taxes, often pushing total sales tax near 8–10% in many areas)

e. Additional Regulatory Costs

·        California’s Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) and Cap-and-Trade programs add an estimated 29–54¢ per gallon in indirect costs, depending on credit prices and compliance costs

. Total Tax Burden

·        When you combine state excise (61.2¢)federal excise (18.4¢)sales tax, and environmental program costs, the effective burden is roughly 90¢ per gallon in direct taxes, and well over $1.20 per gallon when regulatory costs are included—about 25–27% of the pump price at current averages

·       Cigarette Tax – Varies by state; in NYC, it’s as high as $5.85 per pack.

·       Alcohol Tax – State taxes on beer, wine, and spirits; rates vary widely.

·       “Sin Taxes” – Levies on products like tobacco and alcohol, often hidden in the purchase price.

·       Excise Taxes on Goods – Applied to items like tires, airline tickets, and firearms, often unnoticed by consumers.

Here’s an expanded, categorized list of hidden taxes in the U.S. system, along with their impacts on consumers and businesses:

1. Payroll-Related Hidden Taxes

  • Social Security & Medicare (FICA)
    Impact: Reduces take-home pay; employers also bear a matching cost, which indirectly suppresses wages.
  • Unemployment Insurance Taxes
    Impact: Employers pay these, but costs are often passed to employees via lower wage growth.

2. Consumption-Based Hidden Taxes

  • Excise Taxes on Gasoline, Alcohol, Tobacco
    Impact: Embedded in product prices; disproportionately affects lower-income households (regressive).
  • Utility Taxes (Electricity, Gas, Water)
    Impact: Raises household and business operating costs; often unnoticed on monthly bills.
  • Telecom & Cable Taxes
    Impact: Adds to communication costs for consumers and businesses.

3. Regulatory & Compliance Costs (Indirect Taxes)

  • Environmental & Carbon Compliance Fees
    Impact: Businesses pass costs to consumers through higher prices.
  • Healthcare Mandates (ACA-related fees)
    Impact: Raises insurance premiums for employers and employees

5. Corporate Tax Pass-Through

  • Corporate Income Tax
    Impact: Though levied on businesses, costs are shifted to consumers (higher prices), employees (lower wages), and shareholders (lower returns).

6. Investment & Retirement Hidden Taxes

  • Capital Gains Tax on Inflationary Gains
    Impact: Investors pay tax on nominal gains, not real gains, eroding wealth.
  • 401(k) & IRA Withdrawal Taxes
    Impact: Tax deferral creates an illusion of tax-free growth, but withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income.

7. State & Local Hidden Taxes

  • Sales Tax Embedded in Pricing
    Impact: Consumers often underestimate total cost; it is regressive in nature.
  • Property Transfer & Recording Fees
    Impact: Adds hidden costs to real estate transactions.

regressive tax effect means the tax burden falls disproportionately on lower-income individuals because the tax takes a larger percentage of their income compared to higher earners. In simpler terms, it’s like a financial hurdle that’s harder to clear for those with less money. Here’s a detailed breakdown of why and how this happens:

8. Nature of Hidden Taxes

  • Many hidden taxes (excise taxes, utility fees, sales taxes) are flat amounts or percentages on consumption, not income.
  • Lower-income households spend a greater share of their income on necessities (gas, utilities, food), so these taxes consume a bigger portion of their budget.

9. Examples of Regressive Impact

  • Gasoline Tax:
    • A $0.50 per-gallon tax is the same for everyone, but for someone earning $30,000/year, commuting costs might consume 5–10% of income, versus <1% for someone earning $300,000.
  • Utility Taxes:
    • Heating and electricity are essential; low-income families can’t easily reduce usage, so the tax burden is inelastic.
  • “Sin Taxes” (Alcohol, Tobacco):
    • These products have higher consumption rates among lower-income groups, amplifying the regressive effect.

10. Inflation as a Hidden Regressive Tax • Inflation erodes purchasing power without adjusting wages proportionally for low-income earners, making it a stealthy tax. • Wealthier individuals often hold assets that appreciate with inflation, while lower-income households hold cash or fixed wages, making inflation a stealth tax on the poor.

  • Inflation erodes purchasing power without adjusting wages proportionally for low-income earners.
  • Wealthier individuals often hold assets that appreciate with inflation, while lower-income households tend to have cash or fixed incomes, making inflation a stealth tax on the poor.

11. Why It Matters

  • Behavioral Distortion: Low-income households often cut essential spending (such as food and healthcare) to pay these taxes.
  • Wealth Gap Widening: High earners can absorb or offset these costs; low earners cannot.
  • Policy Transparency: Hidden taxes obscure the actual cost of government programs, reducing accountability.

Here’s a ranked list of hidden taxes by regressivity, from most regressive (hits low-income households hardest) to least:

12. Excise Taxes on Tobacco & Alcohol

  • Why Most Regressive:
    • Consumption rates are higher among lower-income groups.
    • A flat per-unit tax means a larger share of income for people with low incomes.
  • Impact:
    • Disproportionate financial strain on low-income households.

13. Gasoline & Fuel Taxes

  • Why:
    • Commuting is often unavoidable for low-income workers.
    • Rural and suburban residents (often lower-income) drive more.
  • Impact:
    • Transportation costs consume a larger share of income.

14. Utility Taxes (Electricity, Gas, Water)

  • Why:
    • Utilities are essential and inelastic; everyone pays similar amounts regardless of income.
  • Impact:
    • Higher effective tax rate for low-income households.

15. Sales Taxes on Goods & Services

  • Why:
    • Lower-income households typically spend nearly all their income on consumption, whereas wealthier families tend to save a larger portion of their income.
  • Impact:
    • The effective tax rate declines as income increases.

16. Telecom & Cable Taxes

  • Why:
    • Communication is a necessity; costs are similar across income levels.
  • Impact:
    • Adds to monthly expenses disproportionately for low earners.

17. Inflation (Monetary Policy as Hidden Tax)

  • Why:
    • Erodes purchasing power; low-income households hold more cash and fewer inflation-protected assets.
  • Impact:
    • Silent wealth transfers from savers to borrowers and asset holders.

18. Corporate Tax Pass-Through

  • Why Less Regressive:
    • Costs are spread across consumers, employees, and shareholders.
  • Impact:
    • Still regressive in pricing but less direct than consumption taxes.

✅ Pattern: The more a tax is tied to necessities and flat rates, the more regressive it becomes.