Dan J. Harkey

Educator & Private Money Lending Consultant

Mastering Real Estate Valuation: The Three Approaches and When to Use Them

Valuing real estate accurately is not just important; it’s crucial for lenders, investors, and property owners. Appraisers rely on three primary approaches to determine market value: the Sales Comparison Approach, the Cost Approach, and the Income Capitalization Approach.

by Dan J. Harkey

Share This Article

Summary

Each method is not just a tool, but a cornerstone in the valuation process, with its own strengths, limitations, and ideal scenarios.

1. Sales Comparison Approach (Market Data Approach)

What It Is:
This method, the Sales Comparison Approach, is a practical and widely used tool in the real estate valuation process. It compares the subject property to recently sold similar properties (called “comps”) in the same market. Adjustments are made for differences in size, condition, location, and amenities.

Ideal Scenario:

  • Residential properties in active markets with plenty of recent sales.

Example:

  • Subject: 2,000 sq. ft. home
  • Comp A: Sold for $500,000, but has a pool (+$15,000 adjustment)
  • Comp B: Sold for $480,000, but is 200 sq. ft. smaller (+$10,000 adjustment)
  • Indicated Value: Around $490,000

2. Cost Approach

What It Is:
The Cost Approach is a versatile method that estimates the cost to replace or reproduce the property’s improvements, subtracts depreciation, and adds the value of the land. It’s a tool that can be applied to a wide range of properties, from new construction to special-purpose properties where comps are scarce.

Ideal Scenario:

  • New construction or special-purpose properties (schools, churches) where comps are scarce.

Example:

  • Land Value: $100,000
  • Replacement Cost: $400,000
  • Depreciation: $50,000
  • Value = $100,000 + ($400,000 – $50,000) = $450,000

3. Income Capitalization Approach (you may review my article on the capitalization approach on my website)

What It Is:
Used for income-producing properties. Convert Net Operating Income (NOI) into value using a capitalization rate or discounted cash flow.

Ideal Scenario:

  • Apartments, office buildings, retail centers—any property generating rental income.

Example (Direct Capitalization):

  • NOI: $120,000
  • Cap Rate: 6%
  • Value = $120,000 ÷ 0.06 = $2,000,000

Comparison Table

Approach

Best For

Strengths

Limitations

Sales Comparison

Homes, condos, active markets

Reflects actual market behavior

Hard if few comps exist

Cost Approach

New builds, special-use assets

Useful when comps are scarce

Depreciation estimates can be subjective

Income Capitalization

Income-producing properties

Focuses on investment performance

Requires accurate income & expense data