Dan J. Harkey

Master Educator | Business & Finance Consultant | Mentor

The Big Lie’s Perpetual Life Lives on Over and Over: Part III of III

by Dan J. Harkey

Share This Article

1) Viral “factoids” that everyone “knows.”

Example: “We only use 10% of our brains.”

  • Where you see it: social media posts, motivational talks, movie dialogue, casual conversation.
  • How the effect shows up: each encounter increases familiarity, and familiarity gets misread as accuracy (“I’ve heard it a lot, so it must be true”).
  • Reality check: It’s a widely repeated myth—not a scientific fact.  (The key point here is how repetition boosts perceived truth.)

Why it’s a perfect illusory-truth example: It spreads because it’s catchy and repeated—not because it’s supported.

2) Health misinformation that feels “common sense.”

Example: “Vitamin C prevents the common cold.”

  • Where you see it: ads for supplements, family advice, wellness blogs, product packaging cues.
  • How repetition happens: repeated exposure across many contexts (ads + friends + “health tips”) increases fluency and perceived truth.
  • Reality check: Researchers explicitly cite this belief as a type of misconception that can enter our knowledge base via repetition.

Big lesson: Health claims are especially vulnerable because people want simple solutions—and repeated claims start to “feel verified.”

3) Advertising claims that “sound right” after enough exposures

Example: “Toning shoes will improve your fitness.”

  • Where you see it: commercials, influencer sponsorships, product pages, in-store displays.
  • How the effect shows up: ads are designed for repetition; fluency rises, skepticism falls, and “it must work” becomes the default feeling.
  • Reality check: This kind of consumer misconception is explicitly referenced as the kind of false claim people encounter in daily life.  [

Marketing doesn’t have to prove—marketing has to repeat.

4) “Fake it till it’s true” workplace lore

Example: “Multitasking makes you more productive.”

  • Where you see it: company culture talk, hustle content, management slogans, job descriptions.
  • How repetition happens: it’s reinforced in meetings, performance reviews, and social norms—so it becomes the “obvious” model of work.
  • Why it fits: the illusory truth effect is about repeated statements gaining a truthy feel; it doesn’t require formal propaganda—just repeated exposure and a plausible narrative.

Reality check (general): Productivity is complex; “multitasking = better” is often an overgeneralization that survives because it’s repeated.

5) Social-media “news” headlines you scroll past repeatedly

Example pattern: A dramatic headline appears on multiple accounts

  • Where you see it: trending feeds, reposts, screenshots, short-form video captions.
  • How the effect shows up: even one prior exposure can increase the chance someone will share the statement later, partly because repetition raises perceived accuracy
  • Reality check: The “it’s everywhere” sensation can be created by algorithms and resharing—not by truth.

Key point: Visibility is not verification.

6) Repeated “finance wisdom” that sounds authoritative

Example: “This indicator ALWAYS predicts the market.”

  • Where you see it: finance influencers, newsletter hooks, simplified charts, TikTok summaries.
  • How repetition happens: the same talking point is repeated with different graphics and confident delivery, increasing fluency.
  • Reality check: Markets rarely obey “always” rules; these claims persist because repetition feels like consensus.

7) “Everyone says…” rumors in communities and schools

Example: “That restaurant fails health inspections all the time.”

  • Where you see it: neighborhood Facebook groups, parent chats, workplace Slack channels.
  • How repetition happens: a rumor gets repeated as a warning; after enough repeats, it becomes “known.”
  • Why it fits: The illusory truth effect doesn’t require people to intend deception; it only requires repeated exposure that increases familiarity and perceived truth.

A quick self-check you can use in the wild

When you notice yourself thinking “I’ve heard that before”, try this:

·         Do I know the source?

·         Have I seen actual evidence, or only repeats?

·         Would this still seem true if I saw it only once?